Here is an excerpt from a paper from Salvano Briceno, Director of the Secretariat of the United Nations International Strategy for Disaster Reduction (UNISDR), which explains why we shouldn't use natural disasters. There are many more older papers on this topic (also the book 'At Risk'), but he gives a very clear explanation:
"The most serious aspect of the threat is the rapid increase in exposure and vulnerability of populations, particularly those in urban areas to natural events, which themselves are increasing but at a much lower speed. Hence, the need to address the disaster risk issue with terms other than ‘‘natural disasters.’’ This reorientation in terminology is essential to avoid creating a misunderstanding of the problem. The concept behind this shift in terminology is that the phrase ‘‘natural disasters’’ conveys the perception that if disasters are natural there is little that can be done, except by preparing to respond to them, instead of reducing vulnerability and building resilience, which need to be the focus of risk reduction and management policies. This is why scholars increasingly try to avoid speaking about ‘‘natural disasters’’ and rather refer only to ‘‘disasters’’ or ‘‘natural hazards.’’ When needed, reference to ‘‘disasters triggered by natural hazards’’ or, more specifically, ‘‘disasters due to vulnerability to natural hazards’’ are the preferred expressions. This terminology revision was an essential component in the negotiations for the HFA. For many government authorities, it has been convenient to blame disasters on nature, hence their preference for maintaining the term ‘‘natural disasters.’’ Despite official reluctance, ‘‘natural disaster’’ is no longer utilized in the HFA document, except in a footnote to explain why it should not be used."
Flood disaster management practices and vulnerability in Japan, the Netherlands and elsewhere.
Thursday, February 26, 2015
Friday, February 6, 2015
Reaction to new Dutch Water Management Plan
In a response to the proposed plan by secretary of state Dijksma, as reported by the Dutch newspaper Trouw, the mayor of one of the Dutch northern islands states that one doesn't inundate islands as the key characteristic of islands is that they are the part remaining above water. One of the ideas in the plan focuses on dynamic coastal management. He points out that the inhabitants have been maintaining the islands for a thousand years, and only during the past 50 years people from the mainland have interfered. He has promoted a dynamic management before.
A representative of the public organization for forest management commented that it is possible at the outer ends of the islands, but the inhabited parts must be kept safe. While there might be more free flowing sand in these areas, at the same time beach nourishment remains necessary to protect the outer coastal dunes. This extra sand may find its way into the fairways, which then have to be dredged again, but this is part of the new plan, as the islands must be kept accessible.
A representative of the public organization for forest management commented that it is possible at the outer ends of the islands, but the inhabited parts must be kept safe. While there might be more free flowing sand in these areas, at the same time beach nourishment remains necessary to protect the outer coastal dunes. This extra sand may find its way into the fairways, which then have to be dredged again, but this is part of the new plan, as the islands must be kept accessible.
Tuesday, February 3, 2015
New Dutch Water Management Plan
The Secretary of State of Nature, Sharon Dijksma, has presented a new plan for the Dutch coast and rivers, entailing plans until 2050. The proposed dynamic management allows natural tides to have a greater impact on the coast line, as it is estimated this will become a cheaper solution. You can download it here (Dutch).
The plan will create more space for water and more interaction between fresh and salt water. It concerns 6 areas in total: the river area, the Ijssel lake, the North Sea, the coastal area, the Wadden Sea, and the South West Delta area. The proposed changes include:
- Coastal area: becomes broader and the sea can change the shape of the coastline, where trees may also grow freely.
- Wadden Sea: dunes will be cut so that the sea may reform uninhabited island areas
- South West Delta area: 50 cm of tides should be allowed to pass through the areas Veerse meer and Grevelingen, and the Biesbosch.
The major losing party in this plan is the fishing industry in the Wadden Sea area, which will be terminated, whereas it will remain possible to gain resources from the area such as salt. The idea is that the plan will lead to nature management that is cheaper to maintain and capable of retaining the extra water climate change is expected to entail.
The ministry of economic affairs is now starting negotiations with civilians, NGOs, local governments, private companies and others in order to start projects complying to the plan's vision.
Friday, January 30, 2015
News in Japan - January
Japan:
20 years after Kobe quake, world rethinks disaster risk Earthquakes expose economic vulnerability to disaster events like no other natural hazard, with the possible exception of recurring extensive floods. They also demonstrate the futility of trying to implement building codes without the buy-in of the private sector. The private sector is responsible for 70 to 85 percent of overall investment in most economies.
USA:
Going with the flow: Is river basin management misguided?
Rescuing farmland after a flood
Other:
Pakistan's coastal villagers retreat as seas gobble land
Greenland Ice: The warmer it gets the faster it melts
Better dam planning strategies
Long list of sustainable development goals likely to stay, UNDP says
Russia's forests overlooked in climate change fight
20 years after Kobe quake, world rethinks disaster risk Earthquakes expose economic vulnerability to disaster events like no other natural hazard, with the possible exception of recurring extensive floods. They also demonstrate the futility of trying to implement building codes without the buy-in of the private sector. The private sector is responsible for 70 to 85 percent of overall investment in most economies.
USA:
Going with the flow: Is river basin management misguided?
Rescuing farmland after a flood
Other:
Pakistan's coastal villagers retreat as seas gobble land
Greenland Ice: The warmer it gets the faster it melts
Better dam planning strategies
Long list of sustainable development goals likely to stay, UNDP says
Russia's forests overlooked in climate change fight
Malawi floods raise fears of cholera outbreak, poor harvest
Thousands stranded in Malawi as floods trigger "slow tsunami"
Thousands stranded in Malawi as floods trigger "slow tsunami"
More rains, more deaths as floods across southern Africa set to worsen Malawi, one of the poorest countries in the world with a population of 16 million, has been hardest hit, with at least 176 confirmed dead and 121,000 displaced.
States, donors must do more to tackle rising disaster risk - UN According to a 2013 report from the London-based Overseas Development Institute, the international community spent $13.5 billion on reducing the risk of damage from disasters in the past two decades - just 40 cents for every $100 of aid.
Toward Resilience: A Guide to Disaster Risk Reduction and Climate Change Adaptation
Board game puts new spin on competitive land-use dynamics
States, donors must do more to tackle rising disaster risk - UN According to a 2013 report from the London-based Overseas Development Institute, the international community spent $13.5 billion on reducing the risk of damage from disasters in the past two decades - just 40 cents for every $100 of aid.
Toward Resilience: A Guide to Disaster Risk Reduction and Climate Change Adaptation
Board game puts new spin on competitive land-use dynamics
Labels:
Africa,
Asia,
Earthquake,
Europe,
Flood,
Middle East,
Preparation,
Recovery,
Response,
UN,
USA,
Water storage
Ice sheets jamming up rivers
Having read on the historic situation of ice in river in the Netherlands, I decided to find out more on this topic. I was already familiar with historical pictures of this situation occurring on the river Rhine (see below, 1789):
I did not expect it, but this is still a matter of importance nowadays. The Manual De-icing Waterways from the Dutch public works institute (2010) tells the history of ice breaking in the Netherlands. It starts with a steamboat with ice breaker active as early as 1861. In the 1960's the government experimented with breaking ice by explosives. Bombs or rockets were found to be ineffective as the loosened ice would easily compact and form new ice walls. Given the current importance of transportation by ship (>30% of all goods transported in the Netherlands), rivers and canals are often kept open and there is no formation of such a high ice wall as in 1789.
In Japan however, while the river geomorphology in Hokkaido should lead to ice break-ups and river jams, due to heavy snow cover this rarely happens. In combination with the low reliance on river transportation, there is no special governmental procedure to break the ice. As observed in the paper
'Aspects of river ice hydrology in Japan' (2002):
"Rivers in northern Japan are subjected to ice formation each winter. They are typically very steep with rapid changes in channel slope. As a result, ice covers are usually discontinuous with open water sections. Winter discharges in Japanese rivers are usually very small. Water temperature and ice production in these streams are very sensitive to the change in air temperature. The open water sections enable the formation of frazil and anchor ice during the winter. Owing to the relatively stable winter weather and heavy snow cover, premature break-up and ice jams rarely occur, even though the channel geometry of these rivers is favourable for their occurrence. In this paper, hydrometeorological factors related to ice-cover formation, frazil and anchor-ice development, and ice-jam formation, as well as measurements of the undercover discharge in rivers in northern Japan are discussed."
What we do find are beautiful river shaped fractures in the lakes in Hokkaido:
Wednesday, January 28, 2015
Dutch flood evacuation remembrance
The Dutch newspaper Trouw reported on the historic near flood 20 years ago in 1995, in the area called Rivierenland (river land) in the Netherlands. While many levees have been reinforced, what is the sentiment of the inhabitants?
An overview of the river projects improving the levees since 1995:
1995-2005: Delta plan great rivers
Since 1996: High water protection program
2006-2015: Elaboration of the river area (NURG)
2007-2015: Space for the River
Since 2014: Delta program
On January 31, 1995, around 240,000 people were evacuated from the river area in the center of the country, after more than 10,000 people evacuated earlier in the Southern province Limburg. Even though the levees have since been reinforced, they are now getting another round of reinforcements. About 200 km of levee has not passed the safety norm tests. In one area this means 58 houses have to be demolished. To encourage the repeated spreading of safety messages, the water board sponsors commemorative plates and theater pieces about the evacuation 20 years ago. One building initiative is called a climate levee, akin to the Japanese superlevee, where the levee is extended in width and people may live on it.
One inhabitant of a town where the levees almost broke has initiated such a commemorative plaque for the almost-flood. In the town Ochten people suddenly had to evacuate within 3 hours, unlike other towns that had more than a day to prepare. After the evacuation, many families moved as they didn't feel safe anymore. But this person feels protected by the new governmental projects to reinforce the levees.
Another inhabitant of the floodplains recalls how they had to evacuate their cattle. Afterwards he was angry at the government for not maintaining the levees and not reimbursing evacuation costs. He joined the water board to make sure this failure would not occur again. He remembers older stories too, from a flood in 1926 his mother experienced where the roof of their house floated away. During the December 1993 high water he already considered what to do in case of an evacuation. During the January 1995 evacuation his family could stay at a vacation park, which was nice for his children who even got swimsuits for free. However, there was a lack of modern communication devices such as mobile phones or internet, and he didn't know the whereabouts of his parents for days. Afterwards he joined the protests against the government plans to not reimburse 100% of the evacuation costs, and now feels proud to be part of the government that then failed to protect the inhabitants. This way he can make sure this is not repeated.
An overview of the river projects improving the levees since 1995:
1995-2005: Delta plan great rivers
Since 1996: High water protection program
2006-2015: Elaboration of the river area (NURG)
2007-2015: Space for the River
Since 2014: Delta program
On January 31, 1995, around 240,000 people were evacuated from the river area in the center of the country, after more than 10,000 people evacuated earlier in the Southern province Limburg. Even though the levees have since been reinforced, they are now getting another round of reinforcements. About 200 km of levee has not passed the safety norm tests. In one area this means 58 houses have to be demolished. To encourage the repeated spreading of safety messages, the water board sponsors commemorative plates and theater pieces about the evacuation 20 years ago. One building initiative is called a climate levee, akin to the Japanese superlevee, where the levee is extended in width and people may live on it.
One inhabitant of a town where the levees almost broke has initiated such a commemorative plaque for the almost-flood. In the town Ochten people suddenly had to evacuate within 3 hours, unlike other towns that had more than a day to prepare. After the evacuation, many families moved as they didn't feel safe anymore. But this person feels protected by the new governmental projects to reinforce the levees.
Another inhabitant of the floodplains recalls how they had to evacuate their cattle. Afterwards he was angry at the government for not maintaining the levees and not reimbursing evacuation costs. He joined the water board to make sure this failure would not occur again. He remembers older stories too, from a flood in 1926 his mother experienced where the roof of their house floated away. During the December 1993 high water he already considered what to do in case of an evacuation. During the January 1995 evacuation his family could stay at a vacation park, which was nice for his children who even got swimsuits for free. However, there was a lack of modern communication devices such as mobile phones or internet, and he didn't know the whereabouts of his parents for days. Afterwards he joined the protests against the government plans to not reimburse 100% of the evacuation costs, and now feels proud to be part of the government that then failed to protect the inhabitants. This way he can make sure this is not repeated.
Labels:
Flood,
Netherlands,
Preparation,
Prevention,
Recovery,
Response,
River
Thursday, January 15, 2015
Great Garuda in Jakarta
Dutch Newspaper Trouw reported on the Great Garuda Masterplan that the engineering company Witteveen+Bos is proposing in Jakarta, Indonesia.
Jakarta is facing an average land subsidence of 7.5 cm annually, but some areas experience 25 cm, which means that flooding is a real threat.The main cause of subsidence is ground water withdrawal, which only increases with increasing urbanization. The rivers meanwhile often become clogged by garbage, and drainage systems are behind in maintenance.The current poor state of levees adds to these problems. Even without climate change and rising sea levels, the city is facing the consequences of unsustainable water management.
The Great Garuda Masterplan is to create a large reservoir between the city and the ocean, which can store water during the rainy season. It has to be located off land as there is no space left on land to build a reservoir. In combination with this, the goal is to both heighten the levees (both for the rivers and the ocean) and clean the rivers, so that in the future the stored water flowing from the rivers to the reservoir may be used as drinking water.
The engineering firm combined the idea of building a reservoir with the opportunity for constructing houses or industrial areas along the edges, to partially gain back the construction costs. They also propose measures to reduce the burden of this construction project on people living in poverty, such as sluices for fishermen to pass through the reservoir.
It will still take 2-3 years before the various levels of the Indonesian government make their final decision on which of the many proposed plans to execute, so we will have to wait and see if Jakarta gets this Garuda reservoir.
The Great Garuda Masterplan is to create a large reservoir between the city and the ocean, which can store water during the rainy season. It has to be located off land as there is no space left on land to build a reservoir. In combination with this, the goal is to both heighten the levees (both for the rivers and the ocean) and clean the rivers, so that in the future the stored water flowing from the rivers to the reservoir may be used as drinking water.
The engineering firm combined the idea of building a reservoir with the opportunity for constructing houses or industrial areas along the edges, to partially gain back the construction costs. They also propose measures to reduce the burden of this construction project on people living in poverty, such as sluices for fishermen to pass through the reservoir.
It will still take 2-3 years before the various levels of the Indonesian government make their final decision on which of the many proposed plans to execute, so we will have to wait and see if Jakarta gets this Garuda reservoir.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

